Muslim bus drivers refuse to let guide dogs on board
By Andy Dolan
UPDATED: 03:14 GMT, 19 July 2010
Comments (236) Share
Blind passengers are being ordered off buses or refused taxi rides because Muslim drivers or passengers object to their 'unclean' guide dogs.
One pensioner, a cancer sufferer, told how had twice been confronted by drivers and asked to get off the bus because of his guide dog, and had also faced hostility at a hospital and in a supermarket over the animal.
The problem to carry guide dogs on religious grounds has become so widespread that the matter was raised in the House of Lords last week, prompting transport minister Norman Baker to warn that a religious objection was not a reason to eject a passenger with a well-behaved guide dog.
'Stunned': George Herridge, 73, was twice asked by bus drivers to leave their vehicles because of his guide dog, a black labrador
While drivers can use their discretion to refuse to carry non-disabled passengers with dogs, they are compelled to accept guide dogs under disability discrimination law.
Yesterday both the Guide Dogs for the Blind Association and the National Federation of the Blind confirmed the problem was common, and, according to the latter organisation was 'getting worse'.
The tension stems from a strand of Islamic teaching which warns against contact with dogs because the animal's saliva was considered to be impure, the Muslim Council of Britain said.
It urged Muslims to show tolerance and common sense over the issue.
'We need to be flexible on this,' a spokesman said. 'Muslim drivers should have no hesitation in allowing guide dogs into their bus or car.
'If a dog does lick you, it's not the end of the world. Just go home and wash yourself.'
George Herridge, 73, a retired hospital maintenance manager, told the Daily Mail he was 'stunned' to be twice asked by bus drivers to leave their vehicles because of his guide dog Andy, a black Labrador.
Mr Herridge, who lives with wife Janet, 69, in Tilehurst, Reading, said that on the first occasion two years ago, he got off at the request of a Muslim driver because some Muslim children on board were 'screaming' because of the dog.
He found himself in a similar scenario in May last year, when a Muslim woman and her children became 'hysterical'. Mr Herridge this time refused the driver's request to alight.
He complained to the bus company which launched an investigation. It later informed him the matter had been dealt with 'internally'.
Jill Allen-King, spokesman for the NFB, said she had been repeatedly left on the kerb by Muslim taxi drivers who refused to take her dog.
One cab driver told her he would have to 'go home now and wash myself' when she tried to enter his car with her dog.
Mr Baker yesterday warned bus and cab companies that, while there were within their rights to ask a passenger to leave if the dog was causing a nuisance, it was 'much more questionable to be asked to remove a dog for religious reasons'.
He added: 'One person's freedom is someone else's restriction.'
In 2006, Muslim minicab driver Abdul Rasheed Majekodumni was fined £200 and ordered to pay £1,200 costs by magistrates in Marylebone, central London, after being prosecuted for failing to comply with the Disability Discrimination Act when he refused to take a blind passenger because her guide dog was 'unclean'.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1295749/Muslim-bus-drivers-refuse-let-guide-dogs-board.html#ixzz1pTe0HpGq
By Andy Dolan
UPDATED: 03:14 GMT, 19 July 2010
Comments (236) Share
Blind passengers are being ordered off buses or refused taxi rides because Muslim drivers or passengers object to their 'unclean' guide dogs.
One pensioner, a cancer sufferer, told how had twice been confronted by drivers and asked to get off the bus because of his guide dog, and had also faced hostility at a hospital and in a supermarket over the animal.
The problem to carry guide dogs on religious grounds has become so widespread that the matter was raised in the House of Lords last week, prompting transport minister Norman Baker to warn that a religious objection was not a reason to eject a passenger with a well-behaved guide dog.
'Stunned': George Herridge, 73, was twice asked by bus drivers to leave their vehicles because of his guide dog, a black labrador
While drivers can use their discretion to refuse to carry non-disabled passengers with dogs, they are compelled to accept guide dogs under disability discrimination law.
Yesterday both the Guide Dogs for the Blind Association and the National Federation of the Blind confirmed the problem was common, and, according to the latter organisation was 'getting worse'.
The tension stems from a strand of Islamic teaching which warns against contact with dogs because the animal's saliva was considered to be impure, the Muslim Council of Britain said.
It urged Muslims to show tolerance and common sense over the issue.
'We need to be flexible on this,' a spokesman said. 'Muslim drivers should have no hesitation in allowing guide dogs into their bus or car.
'If a dog does lick you, it's not the end of the world. Just go home and wash yourself.'
George Herridge, 73, a retired hospital maintenance manager, told the Daily Mail he was 'stunned' to be twice asked by bus drivers to leave their vehicles because of his guide dog Andy, a black Labrador.
Mr Herridge, who lives with wife Janet, 69, in Tilehurst, Reading, said that on the first occasion two years ago, he got off at the request of a Muslim driver because some Muslim children on board were 'screaming' because of the dog.
He found himself in a similar scenario in May last year, when a Muslim woman and her children became 'hysterical'. Mr Herridge this time refused the driver's request to alight.
He complained to the bus company which launched an investigation. It later informed him the matter had been dealt with 'internally'.
Jill Allen-King, spokesman for the NFB, said she had been repeatedly left on the kerb by Muslim taxi drivers who refused to take her dog.
One cab driver told her he would have to 'go home now and wash myself' when she tried to enter his car with her dog.
Mr Baker yesterday warned bus and cab companies that, while there were within their rights to ask a passenger to leave if the dog was causing a nuisance, it was 'much more questionable to be asked to remove a dog for religious reasons'.
He added: 'One person's freedom is someone else's restriction.'
In 2006, Muslim minicab driver Abdul Rasheed Majekodumni was fined £200 and ordered to pay £1,200 costs by magistrates in Marylebone, central London, after being prosecuted for failing to comply with the Disability Discrimination Act when he refused to take a blind passenger because her guide dog was 'unclean'.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1295749/Muslim-bus-drivers-refuse-let-guide-dogs-board.html#ixzz1pTe0HpGq
» Les voeux de Bodhisattva
» Bientôt un mois d'enseignements du Karmapa en ligne
» Le test des trois passoires
» Pourquoi la méditation est au centre de l'apprentissage spirituel .
» Jour de ROUE important dans le calendrier Bouddhiste
» La situation en Birmanie (Myanmar)
» Roman graphique exceptionnel
» Empathie et compassion dans les services de police
» Des arbres , pour l'Arbre .
» La foire aux bonnes nouvelles
» Boîte aux lettres " Besoin de prières"
» Bonne année à tous les membres !
» La Vie et parcours d’un grand maître tibétain Guéshé Lobsang Tengyé 1/2 et 2/2
» Destin Y'a t'il un destin dans le courant boudhiste
» Entre se croire libre et être libre
» Arrêter de Fumer la cigarette
» - L'année du Buffle 2021 -
» La dépression , au niveaux individuel et collectif
» possession éphémère, connaissance éphémère
» LoupsNoire Connaisance ou Ignorance c'est un choix
» Connaissance et conscience de l'ignorance du monde
» Accepter pour se libérer ....
» En finir avec le manque de confiance en soi et la peur du ridicule
» Les glaciers de l'Himalaya sont en train de disparaître , et avec eux , la vie dans ces régions
» Quel est le sens de l'attachement ?
» Méditation analytique et méditation contemplative
» Balance ton masque - COVID-19 / SARS-CoV-2 / Coronavirus
» Pour que l'humanité ait un avenir , lettre de Lama yéshé Losal
» Une très grande Yogini discrète
» Enseignements du Kagyu Meunlam - Aspirations à mettre fin à l'adversité .
» L'oeuf qui ne tue pas la poule
» L'Astrologie Tibétaine - autres signes
» Conseils du Coeur : Aux pessimistes
» Comment accueillir l’angoisse et la peur
» Conflit, COVID et compassion
» Thomas Merton et le dialogue inter-religieux (interview d'Agnès Gros)
» COVID-19 / SARS-CoV-2 / Coronavirus
» Bien-être et résilience (Sa Sainteté le Dalaï Lama)
» Sa Sainteté le Dalaï-Lama : Le monde devrait s'unir pour une réponse mondiale coordonnée au COVID-19
» La coopération : une réponse aux grands défis de notre temps
» Un peu d'humour à la SNCF........
» Dzogchen: Trente conseils donnés du coeur par Gyalwa Longchenpa
» Le monde du doute tout court
» Hypersensibles : la Méditation est-elle la solution ?
» Sur le livre et la lecture
» Rituel annuel, Drouptcheu de Karmapakshi , à Bruxelles
» Le très Vénérable Kangyour Rinpoché
» Le courage de l'éthique dans ce monde
» Actualités politiques internationales: Maxime Vivas: « Les États-Unis sont sur le déclin. Les bêtes blessées sont dangereuses »
» Sûtra: Présentation de la traduction du Gaṇḍavyūha-sūtra par Patrick Carré
» Prochain Kagyu Mönlam en ligne , du 20 au 27 janvier 2021
» Qu'est-ce qui nous empêche de reconnaître la vraie nature de notre esprit ?
» Le livre des Kagyu Meunlam est disponible en Français
» La pensée avant les pensées
» Bonjour à toutes et à tous
» Bonjour à tous, petite présentation
» Bouddhisme et philosophie, la quête commune d’une sagesse
» Evénements virtuels organisé par Paldenshangpa La Boulaye , chaque week-end à partir du 9 janvier 2021
» Enseignements du 17e Karmapa, Ogyen Trinley Dordjé , du 28 décembre 2020 au 3 janvier 2021
» L’enseignement des maîtres à travers la poésie
» Kyabdjé Dudjom Rinpoché: Le Miroir qui révèle ce qu'il faut adopter et ce qu'il faut abandonner
» Nous sommes perpétuellement sous l'empris de l'orgueil .
» À la recherche d'informations
» Dagpo Dratsang, un monastère tibétain en Inde - 1ere et 2ème partie : L’histoire
» Grande retraite de Mahakala avec Kalou Rimpoché, du 16 au 28 décembre 2020
» Voeux: Joyeuses fêtes à tous!
» Ne savez-vous pas ce que veut dire aimer ?
» Hors-castes: Je suis né dans une famille de basse condition!
» Automassage : bienfaits et mode d'emploi
» Demande de témoignages: vie de famille et éveil
» Enseignements en ligne de Tergar Asia par Yongey Mingyour Rimpoché .
» Une étoile de Noël à observer le 21 décembre 2020
» Bonjour à tous - présentation
» Ravie de me joindre à vous